Skip to main content

Private (PKV) vs. Public (GKV) Health Insurance: Is it worth it?

Scale balancing Private and Public Health Insurance

If your salary in Germany goes above the statutory threshold or you become self-employed, at some point you ask yourself: stay in public health insurance (GKV) or switch to private (PKV)? In my view there is no blanket answer. Here I explain which points really matter for the decision and when I would rather advise against PKV.

The Myth of Unaffordable PKV in Old Age

The most common objection to PKV I hear is the fear of unaffordable premiums in old age. Problems arise mainly when someone chose a too tightly calculated cheap tariff when young and spent the savings compared to GKV.

A well-calculated PKV builds aging reserves (Altersrückstellungen) from day one. Part of your monthly premium is invested to cushion rising medical costs later. At age 60, the mandatory 10% statutory surcharge falls away, and daily sick pay (Krankentagegeld) ends on retirement, lowering the monthly bill further.

Public Insurance Contributions Rise Over Time Too

Healthcare inflation hits both systems. In the public system, the contribution ceiling (2026: €69,750 gross) and the fund-specific supplementary rates (Zusatzbeiträge) also increase steadily over the years, so higher earners pay noticeably more today than ten years ago, and that will continue.

Who Benefits From Switching and When to Stay Caution-Minded

I think a lower starting premium is a poor reason to switch. What matters is how your life should look over the coming decades, including family plans and how long you intend to stay in Germany:

  • Employees above the JAEG threshold: Once regular gross pay exceeds €77,400 (2026), you can opt into PKV alongside the employer subsidy. Keep children and a non-working spouse in mind: unlike GKV family cover, PKV charges a separate contribution for each insured person.
  • Freelancers & self-employed professionals: Because you cover both employer and employee shares in GKV yourself, PKV can cost less for stronger cover if health history fits, provided irregular income years are planned for.
  • Health history and age at entry: Pre-existing conditions and entry age determine private rates permanently. Applicants with chronic conditions or several dependents without own income often fare better in GKV.

Expat Health Insurance Check

Find out if you can or must join German Private Health Insurance (PKV) and view your options.

Before Applying: Anonymous Pre-Assessment

Before you sign a PKV application, I clarify your pre-existing conditions through an anonymous pre-assessment. That way you know in advance whether there are surcharges, and you do not risk a rejection you would have to disclose later:

1

Define Coverage Priorities

In an initial call, I go over hospital room options, dental percentages, deductible levels, and sick-pay needs with you.

2

Online Questionnaire via simplr

You fill in a digital health questionnaire via my portal (simplr) calmly using your medical records.

3

Anonymous Request & Tariff Choice

I ask suitable PKV insurers anonymously for preliminary terms and walk through the written feedback with you before choosing.

Contractual Policy Benefits vs. Statutory Return Rules

In PKV, the medical benefits written into your tariff wording remain contractually fixed. In GKV, coverage depends on the statutory benefits catalog (SGB V), which lawmakers can amend. The flip side: from age 55 the way back into GKV is largely closed by law (§ 6 (3a) SGB V). Choosing PKV is therefore a decision for a very long time.

If you are thinking about switching, I am happy to calculate both options with your numbers, including children and retirement. And if GKV suits you better, I will tell you just as openly.

Checklist: Does PKV Fit Your Situation?

  • Does your gross income steadily exceed the JAEG threshold (€77,400)?
  • Can you verify and disclose your medical history for the last 3 to 5 years accurately?
  • Are you prepared to invest early premium savings for higher contributions in retirement?

Comparing PKV vs. GKV?

I calculate whether private or public health insurance fits your income, family plans, and planned stay in Germany.

An easy start: a short, no-obligation 15-minute check via video call.