In Germany, motor liability insurance is mandatory, partial and comprehensive cover are optional. Which combination makes sense depends on the value of your car, your financing and how much risk you can carry yourself. Here I explain what I look for in a comparison and why the cheapest tariff is often not the best one after an accident.
Key Facts at a Glance
Request personal advice →| What is covered | Motor liability for damage to others (mandatory); partial cover (Teilkasko) for theft, glass, storm, hail and collisions with game, among others; fully comprehensive cover (Vollkasko) also for accidents you cause and vandalism. |
|---|---|
| What is not covered | Intentional damage, driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs, wear and tear, and personal belongings in the car. Details |
| Who needs it | Liability cover is mandatory for every registered vehicle; fully comprehensive cover is especially worthwhile for new or financed cars. |
| What does it cost | Rough guide: from under €200 to over €1,000 per year, depending on no-claims class, vehicle, region and comprehensive cover. Non-binding guide value (as of 2026); your premium depends on your situation. You can calculate your exact premium in the comparison calculator on this page. |
| What to look out for | The correct no-claims class (SF-Klasse), listing all drivers correctly, a waiver of the gross negligence defence and a suitable deductible. |
Why "Cheap" Often Ends Up Expensive
Fictional example for illustration; all persons and events are invented.
Dennis recently moved to Germany for his new job. To save money, he chose the cheapest car insurance he could find online. "Insurance is insurance," he thought. "As long as I have a license plate."
On a foggy morning, a deer jumped out of the woods directly in front of his car. He couldn't avoid it. The entire front of his car was destroyed, damage totaling over 8,000 euros.
When he reported the claim, the gaps in his cheap tariff quickly became clear: while the collision with the deer itself was covered, the consequential engine damage caused by leaking fluids was excluded in the fine print. Because he had also agreed to a workshop binding clause to save 20 euros a year, his car had to be towed to a partner shop far from home.
In the end, he had to pay over 2,000 euros out of pocket because his bargain tariff lacked consequential damage cover. Afterwards, he switched to a tariff covering collisions with animals of all kinds, marten bites including consequential damage, and a waiver of the gross negligence objection (§ 81 (2) VVG).
What Makes a Good Car Insurance Plan?
Most people focus solely on price. When an accident happens, contract wording decides what gets paid. Here are the three core modules:
1. Liability (Haftpflicht): Statutory Mandatory Cover (§ 1 PflVG)
In Germany, no registered car is allowed on public roads without motor liability insurance (§ 1 PflVG). It pays for damage you cause to others, and under § 115 VVG injured parties even have a direct legal claim against the liability insurer. While the statutory minimum coverage sums under § 4 (2) PflVG (annex) are only 7.5 million euros for personal injury, 1.3 million euros for property damage, and 50,000 euros for pure financial loss, a good tariff should provide lump-sum coverage of 100 million euros.
2. Partial Casco (Teilkasko): Protection Against Nature and Theft
Partial Casco is voluntary but very sensible. It protects your own car from things out of your control:
- Glass Breakage: A stone chip in the windshield is common. Partial Casco pays for the replacement or repair.
- Wildlife Accidents: Collisions with animals. Look for "animals of all kinds" coverage, not just "game animals."
- Theft: If your car or parts of it (like the navigation system) are stolen.
- Storm, Hail, and Lightning: When severe weather damages your vehicle.
- Marten Bites: Small rodents love cables. A good policy pays for the cable and the expensive consequential engine damage.
3. Full Casco (Vollkasko): The All-Round Protection
Full Casco includes everything from Partial Casco and adds more. It pays even if:
- You are at fault: You had a moment of inattention and hit the car in front? Full Casco repairs your car.
- Vandalism: Someone scratches your paint or kicks off a mirror at night.
- Hit and Run: Someone hits your parked car and disappears.
Why Personal Advice Matters
Comparison portals sort first by annual price. A broker reviews the policy wording behind that price.
In my neutral online consultation, I check the clauses automated tables easily miss. Does the comprehensive cover waive the "objection of gross negligence" under § 81 (2) VVG (aside from standard exclusions such as driving under alcohol or drugs)? How long does new-value or purchase-price compensation apply before falling back to depreciated market value?
And if an accident happens, you do not wait in an anonymous call-center queue. You message me directly. Knowing your policy terms, I help you report the claim properly and on time, as far as I can.
Standard Application Requirements
- Valid German Address (Anmeldung)
- German Bank Account (IBAN)
What Is Not Covered
Even fully comprehensive cover does not pay in every case. These situations are typically excluded or restricted:
- Intentional damage: Damage caused on purpose is not covered.
- Alcohol and drugs: Anyone who drives under the influence risks reduced benefits under comprehensive cover and a recourse claim by the insurer under liability cover.
- Gross negligence: For example running a red light: without a corresponding clause, comprehensive cover may reduce its payment.
- Wear and tear and operating damage: Defects caused by wear or operating errors, for example to the engine, are not covered by comprehensive insurance.
- Drivers not listed: If someone drives who is not named in the contract, you may face additional premiums or contractual penalties.
- Belongings in the car: Bags or laptops stolen from the vehicle are, if at all, covered by household contents insurance.
How I Help You in the Event of a Claim
As your broker, I am legally on your side, not the insurer's, and that matters most when something happens. This is how we proceed:
-
1. Report it quickly
Let me know as soon as possible, by WhatsApp, phone, email or directly in the simplr app. Many policy conditions require prompt notification.
-
2. Document everything
Keep photos, invoices, reports and the names of everyone involved. Good documentation speeds up processing considerably. How to write the claim report.
-
3. Record the accident properly
Secure the scene, exchange names, number plates and insurance details and take photos. Call the police if anyone is injured or if there is a dispute about what happened. Talk to me before any repair.
-
4. I help with the report
As far as I can, I help you report the claim fully and on time and tell you which evidence the insurer needs. The insurer handles and settles the claim. If it refuses or cuts benefits, we look at the reasons together. What to do after a denial.
Car & E-Scooter Calculator: Compare Rates Yourself
Calculate your premium quickly and easily. Use the comparison tool for cars, motorcycles, mopeds, and e-scooters in Germany.
Comparison calculator by NAFI GmbH
To protect your data, the calculator only loads after you click. Your IP address is then transmitted to NAFI GmbH, which may also set cookies. Details in the Privacy Policy.
Please note: this calculator is provided by a German platform and is only available in German. If you prefer a comparison in English, message me or book a short call.