Skip to main content

ETF Net Policy: Retirement Investing Without Built-In Commissions

With an ETF net policy (Nettopolice), your savings go into the chosen ETFs from the start, because no acquisition or trail commissions are built in (no Zillmerung). Instead, you pay me separately with a fee for arranging it. Over long terms this often keeps more money invested, plus the tax advantages of the insurance wrapper from age 62. Here I explain who it pays off for and who it does not.

Reading time: about 4 minutes

Key Facts at a Glance

Request personal advice →
What it provides An ETF pension insurance without built-in acquisition commission; you pay me separately for arranging it through a fee.
Limits and drawbacks The separate fee, which depending on the agreement remains payable even on early cancellation, and market risk. Details
Who needs it For anyone saving for retirement with ETFs over the long term who wants to see the costs clearly.
What does it cost It depends on your personal situation. I will gladly prepare a non-binding quote for you: get in touch.
What to look out for The amount and payment terms of my fee, ongoing costs, choice of ETFs and the tax advantages at payout.

Miriam and Florian's Story: Full ETF Returns Without Hidden Commissions

Fictional example for illustration; all persons and events are invented.

Miriam and Florian live in Germany: Florian works as an engineer, and Miriam is a freelance designer. Both already use a regular ETF brokerage account for mid-term reserves, but they wanted a tax-efficient core pillar for their long-term retirement provision.

Florian and Miriam had already looked at an offer for a traditional pension insurance policy, where nearly €4,000 in acquisition and distribution commissions would have been deducted in the first five years alone. At the same time, they needed a contract that stays adaptable when Miriam's freelance income fluctuates. They wanted a pension plan where their contributions work for compound interest from day one.

I set up a commission-free net policy for both of them using ETFs. They agreed a fee with me in advance for arranging it, which they pay separately. Because there is no front-loaded commission (Zillmerung) and no ongoing trail commission, 100% of their contributions flow directly into low-cost global ETFs, while values fluctuate with the capital markets. At the same time, they can adjust their monthly savings rate, make lump-sum top-ups, or withdraw partial amounts within the contract rules while switching funds tax-free inside the insurance wrapper.

Why Waiving Acquisition Commissions Changes the Cost Balance

In a traditional gross pension policy (Bruttopolice), upfront acquisition commissions of 2.5% to 4% of the total lifetime contribution sum are typically deducted from your payments during the first five years (a practice known as Zillmerung). As a result, early surrender values start low right at the beginning of the savings phase.

An ETF net policy leaves out built-in acquisition and trail commissions. Your contributions are invested 100% from the first euro into low-cost ETFs, with effective contract costs often below 0.5% p.a. Through a neutral market comparison, I compare providers based on costs, fund selection, and annuity factors. My separate brokerage fee (Honorar) still has to be factored in: for example calculations I estimate €1,000 to €1,500, and the actual amount is always agreed in writing beforehand. Processing normally runs through the broker pool Nettowelt GmbH, and via DIPAY only in agreed exceptions.

Long-Term Retirement Saving with High Contractual Flexibility

Although a net policy is built for long-term wealth accumulation until retirement from age 62, it never locks you into rigid payment obligations. You remain in full control of your contribution plan and payout options:

  • No Zillmerung: 100% of your contributions are invested from the first euro without upfront commission deductions.
  • Tax-Free Rebalancing: Switch ETFs or shift into lower-volatility assets before retirement without triggering capital gains tax or annual prepayment tax (Vorabpauschale).
  • Half-Income Rule & Ertragsanteil: From age 62 (after at least 12 years), half of gains on a lump-sum payout are tax-free under current German law (resulting in 42.5% taxable gains after the 15% partial exemption), or you can choose a lifelong annuity with earnings-portion taxation. For binding tax questions or moves abroad, ask a tax advisor (§ 5 StBerG).
  • Flexible Contributions & Withdrawals: Adjust or pause monthly rates, add lump sums, or make partial withdrawals within the policy terms.

Requirements for Foreign Residents

  • Valid German Address (Anmeldung)
  • German Bank Account (IBAN)
  • German Tax ID (and check tax residency rules if moving abroad later)

The Fee: How You Pay for My Work

Commission-free does not mean free of charge. With a net policy no insurer pays me a commission, so you pay me directly through a fee (Honorar). We agree the amount and payment terms explicitly in advance, and without that agreement no fee is due.

The fee agreement is a separate contract alongside your policy. I usually arrange net tariffs through Nettowelt GmbH, a broker pool for net policies. The application, the fee agreement and the billing of the fee run through it. Only in exceptional cases and by arrangement does the fee agreement go through the DIPAY platform instead, which I otherwise use for my service agreements. The fee is collected separately from your savings contribution, and your contribution to the insurer is not affected.

Limits and Drawbacks

A net policy is usually considerably cheaper than a traditional gross policy. You should still know this:

  • Fee: You pay it on top of your contributions, even when markets do badly. Depending on the agreement it remains payable even if you cancel the policy early.
  • Market risk: The value of the ETFs fluctuates; there is usually no guarantee.
  • Long horizon: The tax advantages only apply to payouts after your 62nd birthday and after a term of at least 12 years.

Frequently Asked Questions

What exactly is a net policy?
A net policy (Honorartarif) is a unit-linked ETF pension insurance for long-term retirement savings that excludes built-in acquisition commissions (no Zillmerung) and ongoing trail commissions. As a result, 100% of your contributions flow into low-cost global ETFs from the first euro, with low effective contract costs (often below 0.5% p.a.). Instead of hidden commissions, you agree a separate fee (Honorar) with me for arranging the policy.
What fee do I pay with a net policy?
Because the tariff contains no commission, you pay me directly for arranging the contract through a fee (Honorar). We agree the amount and payment terms explicitly in advance, and without that agreement no fee is due. The agreement and billing usually run through the broker pool Nettowelt, and only in exceptional cases, by arrangement, through the DIPAY platform.
How does a net policy differ from a gross policy and a bank brokerage account?
Compared to a traditional gross policy, there are no built-in acquisition and distribution charges that would otherwise reduce your capital in the first five years. You pay me a separate fee instead. Depending on the fee and the term, this can leave thousands of euros more in the contract. Compared to a regular bank depot, the insurance wrapper gives you tax-free rebalancing without annual prepayment tax (Vorabpauschale), the half-income rule (Halbeinkünfteverfahren) from age 62 after 12 years, or a lifelong annuity with favorable earnings-portion taxation (Ertragsanteil).
Are there long fixed terms?
No, although designed for long-term retirement saving, modern net policies offer high contractual flexibility. You can make additional lump-sum payments, take partial withdrawals, or adjust the plan at any time without surrender penalties.
What are the tax benefits?
You pay no capital gains tax on switches or rebalancing and no annual advance lump-sum tax while the money stays in the policy. For a lump-sum payout after at least 12 years and from age 62, the half-income rule applies (after the 15% partial exemption for unit-linked policies, only 42.5% of gains are taxed at your personal rate), or you can choose a lifelong annuity taxed only on the low statutory earnings portion (Ertragsanteil, e.g. just 17% when the annuity starts at age 67).
Can I change my monthly savings amount?
Depending on the tariff terms, you can increase, lower, or pause your monthly contributions. You can also make additional lump-sum payments if you receive a bonus or an inheritance.
Is my money safe in a net policy?
Your money is invested in broadly diversified global ETFs, which spreads single-stock risk, though ETF values still fluctuate with the stock market. On top of that, your fund units are held in the insurer's statutory guarantee assets (Sicherungsvermögen under § 125 VAG), kept strictly separate from the insurer's other assets in the event of insolvency.

Guides:

Legal Note: Investment involves risk. Past performance is not indicative of future results. I provide neutral market comparisons to find the most cost-effective and highest-performing solutions for your goals.

Check Whether a Net Policy Fits Your Situation

I compare gross and net ETF pension tariffs for your numbers in an online consultation. A separate fee (Honorar) only applies if we explicitly agree on one in writing beforehand.

An easy start: a short, no-obligation 15-minute check via video call.